Papers · Free Culture 2005

The papers, grouped by what they argued

Fifteen papers came out of the 2005 call. The editors list them with their authors and sort them into the four conversations they actually formed.

EventFree Culture and the Digital Library
DateOctober 14, 2005
Papers15 listed presentations
PlatformOpen Conference Systems (PKP)
PDFMetaScholar briefing: Free Culture proceedings/publications/FreeCultureandtheDigitalLibrary.pdf
MetaScholar — Papers · Free Culture 2005
record.xmlnotes.mdsources.txt
All collectionsSymposia06Projects07Photographs02Documents06Journal20
Papers · Free Culture 2005
oai_dcindexedneeds review
1<record status="active">
2 <dc:relation>/events/2005/freeculture/papers.php</dc:relation>
3</record>
Record
EventFree Culture and the Digital
DateOctober 14, 2005
Papers15 listed presentations
PlatformOpen Conference Systems (PKP
Publish

About this list

The original page for this symposium was generated by Open Conference Systems, the Public Knowledge Project's conference software. It let visitors browse presenters by author or title and search abstracts and full texts. That software and its database are gone. What survives is the list of presenters and paper titles, reproduced below with affiliations as the original page gave them.

The list covers the papers accepted for Free Culture and the Digital Library, held at Emory University on October 14, 2005, by the MetaScholar Initiative. The featured speakers, Lawrence Lessig and Siva Vaidhyanathan, gave invited talks and do not appear here as paper authors.

The titles below are lightly normalized to sentence case. Where the original listed no affiliation, none is added. The editors have not seen most full texts and do not summarize papers they have not read.

One abstract did survive in full. The editors have written a summary of Edward Fox's abstract on electronic theses and dissertations.

Law, rights and orphan works

The largest cluster dealt with what the law allowed libraries to do. Marjorie Heins of the Brennan Center for Justice asked whether fair use could survive digital distribution. Two papers took on orphan works, material whose rights holders cannot be found.

William Maher of the University of Illinois Archives focused on unpublished orphan works: letters, diaries and records that archives hold but cannot safely share. Denise Troll Covey of Carnegie Mellon analyzed responses to the United States Copyright Office's inquiry on the same problem, looking at proposals for registries and remedies.

Barrie Howard of the Digital Library Federation wrote about how regulation shapes digital library work. Karrie Peterson and James A. Jacobs asked whether government information in digital form was becoming freer or more controlled.

Read together, these papers made a single point. A collection's usefulness depends on its rights status as much as on its technology. Libraries that cannot clear rights cannot share, no matter how good their systems are.

Papers · Free Culture 2005
The papers, grouped by what they argued

Open repositories that already worked

A second group described services that were already running and already open. These papers had evidence rather than proposals.

Simeon Warner of Cornell reported on fourteen years of the arXiv preprint server, by then a routine part of physics and mathematics publishing. Edward Fox of Virginia Tech described the Networked Digital Library of Theses and Dissertations, which aggregated records from many universities using the OAI protocol for metadata harvesting.

Raymond Puzio and Robert Milson came from the free mathematics community. Puzio wrote about bottlenecks that could slow open mathematical resources. Milson looked at adapting commons-based peer production platforms for teaching. Joseph Corneli proposed a document model built on scholia, layered commentary in the tradition of annotated texts, for peer-produced work.

These papers share a technical thread. Open access at scale relied on simple, shared protocols such as OAI-PMH and on communities willing to maintain them.

People and institutions

The last group asked who would drive change. Daniel Mayer used Wikipedia to argue that trusting users can produce reliable reference work. Debora Halbert cast librarians as potential revolutionaries in cultural exchange and preservation. Meghan Miller Brawley described librarians as catalysts for open access.

Two Emory-connected voices addressed the library's own future. Aaron Krowne argued that free culture could save digital libraries rather than threaten them. Bradley Daigle of the University of Virginia asked the harder follow-up question: how digital scholarship gets sustained once it exists.

Daigle's question set up the next two years of the series. Sustainability stopped being a closing remark and became a programme theme, with funders, consortia and commercial services invited to answer it. The MetaScholar Initiative returned to it directly at the Sustaining Digital Libraries symposium in 2006.

The editors' briefing on the proceedings is available as Free Culture and the Digital Library.

#collections — thread
AR
Archivist

Pulled the files for “The papers, grouped by what they argued”. Folder names are inconsistent, I will map them before ingest.

ML
Metadata librarian

Use the same crosswalk as last time. Dates go to ISO 8601, places to the gazetteer.

crosswalk-v3.xsl · 42 rules
ED
MetaScholar editor

Once the record is clean we link it from the archive page and the journal piece.

Papers

A scholia-based document model for commons-based peer production

Joseph Corneli

Peer production
How do we sustain digital scholarship?

Bradley Daigle, University of Virginia

Sustainability
It is easy for universities to support free culture with digital libraries: the NDLTD example

Edward Fox, Virginia Tech

Theses and dissertations
The librarian revolutionary: creating cultural exchange and preservation on the internet

Debora Halbert, Otterbein College

Libraries
Will fair use survive the digital age?

Marjorie Heins, Brennan Center for Justice, NYU School of Law

Law
Greasing the wheels of regulation

Barrie Howard, Digital Library Federation

Policy
How free culture will save digital libraries

Aaron Krowne, Emory University

Digital libraries
Heritage and culture under lock, but no key: the problem of unpublished orphan works

William Maher, University of Illinois Archives

Orphan works
Trusting the user: Wikipedia as an example

Daniel Mayer

Peer production
Catalysts for change: librarians and open access

Meghan Miller Brawley, University of Tennessee

Open access
Adapting CBPP platforms for instructional delivery

Robert Milson, Dalhousie University

Teaching
Government information in the digital era: free culture or controlled substance?

Karrie Peterson, NCSU Libraries; James A. Jacobs, UC San Diego

Government information
Free math and potential bottlenecks

Raymond Puzio, University of Memphis

Mathematics
Rights, registries, and remedies: responses to the Copyright Office inquiry on orphan works

Denise Troll Covey, Carnegie Mellon University Libraries

Orphan works
The arXiv: 14 years of open access scientific communication

Simeon Warner, Cornell Information Science

Preprints